Contracts: Third Party Problems

  • Third-Party Beneficiary Law – where 2 people enter a contract with the intent to benefit a third party.
    • Third-party Beneficiary (TPB) can enforce the contract.
    • Examples: Insurance contracts; other intended beneficiaries.
    • Vocab:
      • Third-party beneficiary: a person who did not make a contract, but still has rights under it because the contract was intended to benefit him.
      • Promisor: the person who promises to perform for the third party.
      • Promisee: the person who secures the promise.
      • Intended/incidental beneficiary: A third party named in the contract is an intended beneficiary; otherwise, he’s an incidental beneficiary.
        • Only an intended beneficiary has legal rights. Not an incidental beneficiary.
      • Creditor/donee beneficiary: If the promisee’s main reason for entering the contract is to discharge a debt owed to the third party, the third party is a creditor beneficiary; otherwise, he is a donee beneficiary. [Note: most TPB’s are donee beneficiaries.]
    • The promisor and promisee can rescind or modify the contract until the rights of the third party beneficiary have vested.
      • Vested: when TPB learns of the contract and relies on it. The contract cannot be rescinded or modified without the consent of TPB.
        • Exception: where the language of the contract lets the promisee change beneficiaries.
    • Rights of a TPB.
      • TPB can sue the breaching promisor even though there is no privity of contract between them
      • Promisor can raise the same defenses against the TPB it could have raised against the promisee.
      • Only a creditor beneficiary can sue the promisee, not a donee beneficiary.
    • The promisee can recover from the breaching promisor.